2008 Senate Races at a Glance
I haven't been following the pending Senate matchups of 2008 very closely in the last few months, but the conventional wisdom is that Democrats are poised to make modest-to-substantial gains with few if any losses. It's far too early to tell if that will be the case, but I'm skeptical that it will be the Democratic bonanza currently predicted. True, I didn't believe the Dems were gonna pick up six Senate seats last fall either, but the logistics of 2006 (a midterm election year which many Republican voters sat out) helped significantly in securing the narrow Democratic margins in a number of red-state Senate contests. The higher-turnout Presidential contest of 2008 is likely to be a different ballgame entirely, particularly if Hillary Clinton is the nominee and generating ugly counter-coattails in most states.
Here are my general thoughts on the 2008 races, state by state.....
Alabama--Conservative Republican Jeff Sessions is up for re-election and would seem to be a shoo-in. There's a push for some statewide elected officer (Agriculture Secretary I believe) named Ron Sparks to hop in the race on the Democratic side, but I expect that some kid would shoot an 1,100-pound wild pig in the Alabama woods before a Democrat gets elected to a federal office in Alabama. Okay, bad example....but Sessions should still cruise to the finish line.
Alaska--There's some rumors of long-standing Republican curmudgeon Ted Stevens being emboiled in a mini-scandal, but unless he's either indicted or dead, Stevens will win by his usual 80%+ margin.
Arkansas--Conservative Democrat Mark Pryor is probably gonna win re-election, and may not even be battered bloody by the prospect of a Hillary candidacy given Hillary's Arkansas roots. The only caveat would be the prospect of former Republican Governor Mike Huckabee abandoning his Presidential bid and running against Pryor for the open Senate race. Huckabee has expressed no interest in doing so, but if he did, would give Pryor a run for his money.
Colorado--One of the Democrats best pick-up opportunities is Colorado, where incumbent Republican Wayne Allard is retiring. Popular Democratic Congressman Mark Udall is the likely nominee on the donk side, while a number of prominent Republicans could end up throwing their hats in the ring. If I had to put money on it at this stage, I'd bet Udall continues the Democratic Party's momentum in Colorado and pick up this seat, but as with all open seats, there's no way of knowing which direction things will go.
Delaware--Will Joe Biden retire from the Senate after his latest bid for the Presidency inevitably fails? I actually think he will, setting himself up for a Cabinet position in a would-be Democratic administration. Even without Biden on the ticket, you have to like the Democrats' odds at holding the Delaware Senate seat in 2008.
Georgia--The only Democrat who could win federal office in Georgia these days is Zell Miller, and given that nobody in the Democratic Party has any interest in bringing the deranged Miller back to the Senate, Republican Saxby Chambliss should score a safe double-digit re-election margin next year.
Idaho--Unless he retires, Republican Larry Craig will be re-elected. If he does retire, another Republican will follow in his footsteps. Take it to the bank.
Illinois--Despite a rhetorical blunder a couple of years ago, Democrat Dick Durbin is virtually assured of re-election in 2008.
Iowa--Given his penchant for over-the-top rhetoric in a culturally conservative state, Democrat Tom Harkin can never be completely counted upon for victory, but is nonetheless greatly favored in 2008 against any Republican that may choose to challenge him, particularly with Harkin poised to deliver pork by the bucket full to Iowa farmers as the chairman of the Senate Agriculture Committee working on the upcoming farm bill.
Kansas--Republican Pat Roberts will be re-elected by 2-1 or better.
Kentucky--Republican Senate Leader Mitch McConnell will be re-elected by 2-1 or better.
Louisiana--Despite the GOP's failure to secure a top-tier challenger to two-term Democratic incumbent Mary Landrieu, I still can't imagine a scenario where Landrieu gets re-elected given the changed demographics of post-Katrina Louisiana (fewer blacks) during a Presidential election year where any of the major Democratic candidates (Hillary, Obama, Edwards) will be about as popular as diarrhea in Louisiana. Place your bets on the Republicans picking up this seat.
Maine--Popular Republican moderate Susan Collins is being challenged by Democratic House member Tom Allen. Early polls show Collins leading 2-1, and while the outcome is not likely to be that lopsided, look for Collins to hang on by a comfortable margin.
Massachusetts--Since I haven't heard otherwise, I'll operate under the assumption that John Kerry is planning to run for another term in the Senate. Whether he does or doesn't, the Massachusetts Senate seat will remain in Democratic hands.
Michigan--Long-time Democratic incumbent Carl Levin is high-profile enough to overpower any Republican rivals, or at least he should be in economically volatile Michigan where voters are likely to be unpredictable.
Minnesota--Republican Norm Coleman is on the short list of most vulnerable incumbents, but he's a skilled politician who knows exactly what to do to win support among the suburban moderates needed to win in Minnesota. If Coleman faces off against Al Franken, it'll be a blow out in favor of Coleman. If Mike Ciresi gets the Democratic nomination, Coleman will win by a more modest margin.
Mississippi--Conventional wisdom is that geriatric Republican Thad Cochran plans to run for re-election. If he does, Election Night 2008 will be another coronation for him. If he doesn't, there's zero chance a Democrat wins a Mississippi Senate race....including former Attorney General Mike Moore who wouldn't get within seven points of a Republican in MS with Hillary or Obama at the top of the ticket.
Montana--It certainly is likely that long-time incumbent Democrat Max Baucus will be re-elected, but in a Presidential election year in Montana, Baucus could conceivably be taken down by a capable Republican challenger.
Nebraska--Unless he runs for President third-party with Mike Bloomberg, Chuck Hagel will be re-elected to the U.S. Senate for Nebraska. If Hagel doesn't run for Senate re-election, another Republican will win the seat.
New Hampshire--Tough call on this one. One-term GOP incumbent John Sununu is definitely vulnerable, but until I know the significance of his future Democratic challenger, I have to give Sununu a slight edge.
New Jersey--Democratic incumbent Frank Lautenberg is a very old man, but nonetheless seems poised to run for another term in the Senate next year. Lautenberg has low approval ratings, but so do all New Jersey politicians. I'm confident Lautenberg will dispatch any Republican challenger that might be thrown at him.
New Mexico--Pete Domenici is in hot water over his role in the U.S. Attorney firings....and may retire anyway. My bet is that Domenici runs again and gets re-elected. If he doesn't run, the Democrats may have a slight advantage in winning the open seat, but only a tiny one if Republican Congresswoman Heather Wilson runs (even though I doubt she'd abandon her House seat).
North Carolina--Lame Republican incumbent Elizabeth Dole is vulnerable, but it would take a special kind of Democrat to defeat her in a Presidential election year. Governor Mike Easley might be such a guy, but even in an Easley-Dole faceoff, I'd have to give a slight advantage to Dole considering the circumstances. Winnable, but an extreme longshot. I said last year that I expected it to be a generation before a Democrat won another Senate seat in the Old Confederacy outside of Arkansas. I still feel that way.
Oklahoma--Wingnut Republican James Inhofe is a shoo-in for re-election.
Oregon--Moderate Republican Gordon Smith is gonna be very hard to take down no matter which Democrat challenges him. I'll be stunned if Smith gets beaten.
Rhode Island--Democrat Jack Reed wins in a landslide.
South Carolina--He might face a tough primary challenge on the right for cooperating too much with those nasty Democrats, but Republican Lindsay Graham will nonetheless prevail handily in both the primary and the general election.
South Dakota--I'm doubtful that Democrat Tim Johnson will be well enough to run for re-election next year. If he isn't, Republicans will be strongly favored to pick up this seat. Democratic Congresswoman Stephanie Herseth may have even odds if she decided to run, but I honestly hope she doesn't because we can't afford to lose that House seat for a Senate run gamble. Bottom line: I'm betting the GOP gains a seat here.
Tennessee--Republican Lamar Alexander crushes any Democratic challenger that steps in his path.
Texas--The Democrats are delusionally optimistic about toppling one-term incumbent John Cornyn....in Texas.....with either Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, or John Edwards at the top of the ticket. I can't think of any Texas Democrat capable of getting within five points of Cornyn.....or any other candidate with an (R) next to his name for that matter.
Virginia--If Republican John Warner decides to run for another term (pretty much even odds on that bet right now), he'll win. If he doesn't, the Democrats have a modest chance of picking up a seat, particularly if former Governor Mark Warner runs. But the Republicans have a pretty solid bench of their own in Virginia, so don't count them out even if Warner (John that is) ends up retiring.
West Virginia--I submit that Shelley Moore Capito could take Democratic incumbent Jay Rockefeller if she challenged him in increasingly Republican West Virginia, but there's no indication that will happen at this stage, and until it does, you have to bet on Rockefeller.
Wyoming--Republican incumbent Mike Enzi is re-elected handily.
So there you have it. Even under my most optimistic prognosis, the Democrats are only poised to net one seat in 2008. It's way too early to give any merit to these predictions, but I'd be shocked if either party gained more than two seats in the 2008 cycle. It'll be interesting to watch the contests unfold in the months ahead.
Here are my general thoughts on the 2008 races, state by state.....
Alabama--Conservative Republican Jeff Sessions is up for re-election and would seem to be a shoo-in. There's a push for some statewide elected officer (Agriculture Secretary I believe) named Ron Sparks to hop in the race on the Democratic side, but I expect that some kid would shoot an 1,100-pound wild pig in the Alabama woods before a Democrat gets elected to a federal office in Alabama. Okay, bad example....but Sessions should still cruise to the finish line.
Alaska--There's some rumors of long-standing Republican curmudgeon Ted Stevens being emboiled in a mini-scandal, but unless he's either indicted or dead, Stevens will win by his usual 80%+ margin.
Arkansas--Conservative Democrat Mark Pryor is probably gonna win re-election, and may not even be battered bloody by the prospect of a Hillary candidacy given Hillary's Arkansas roots. The only caveat would be the prospect of former Republican Governor Mike Huckabee abandoning his Presidential bid and running against Pryor for the open Senate race. Huckabee has expressed no interest in doing so, but if he did, would give Pryor a run for his money.
Colorado--One of the Democrats best pick-up opportunities is Colorado, where incumbent Republican Wayne Allard is retiring. Popular Democratic Congressman Mark Udall is the likely nominee on the donk side, while a number of prominent Republicans could end up throwing their hats in the ring. If I had to put money on it at this stage, I'd bet Udall continues the Democratic Party's momentum in Colorado and pick up this seat, but as with all open seats, there's no way of knowing which direction things will go.
Delaware--Will Joe Biden retire from the Senate after his latest bid for the Presidency inevitably fails? I actually think he will, setting himself up for a Cabinet position in a would-be Democratic administration. Even without Biden on the ticket, you have to like the Democrats' odds at holding the Delaware Senate seat in 2008.
Georgia--The only Democrat who could win federal office in Georgia these days is Zell Miller, and given that nobody in the Democratic Party has any interest in bringing the deranged Miller back to the Senate, Republican Saxby Chambliss should score a safe double-digit re-election margin next year.
Idaho--Unless he retires, Republican Larry Craig will be re-elected. If he does retire, another Republican will follow in his footsteps. Take it to the bank.
Illinois--Despite a rhetorical blunder a couple of years ago, Democrat Dick Durbin is virtually assured of re-election in 2008.
Iowa--Given his penchant for over-the-top rhetoric in a culturally conservative state, Democrat Tom Harkin can never be completely counted upon for victory, but is nonetheless greatly favored in 2008 against any Republican that may choose to challenge him, particularly with Harkin poised to deliver pork by the bucket full to Iowa farmers as the chairman of the Senate Agriculture Committee working on the upcoming farm bill.
Kansas--Republican Pat Roberts will be re-elected by 2-1 or better.
Kentucky--Republican Senate Leader Mitch McConnell will be re-elected by 2-1 or better.
Louisiana--Despite the GOP's failure to secure a top-tier challenger to two-term Democratic incumbent Mary Landrieu, I still can't imagine a scenario where Landrieu gets re-elected given the changed demographics of post-Katrina Louisiana (fewer blacks) during a Presidential election year where any of the major Democratic candidates (Hillary, Obama, Edwards) will be about as popular as diarrhea in Louisiana. Place your bets on the Republicans picking up this seat.
Maine--Popular Republican moderate Susan Collins is being challenged by Democratic House member Tom Allen. Early polls show Collins leading 2-1, and while the outcome is not likely to be that lopsided, look for Collins to hang on by a comfortable margin.
Massachusetts--Since I haven't heard otherwise, I'll operate under the assumption that John Kerry is planning to run for another term in the Senate. Whether he does or doesn't, the Massachusetts Senate seat will remain in Democratic hands.
Michigan--Long-time Democratic incumbent Carl Levin is high-profile enough to overpower any Republican rivals, or at least he should be in economically volatile Michigan where voters are likely to be unpredictable.
Minnesota--Republican Norm Coleman is on the short list of most vulnerable incumbents, but he's a skilled politician who knows exactly what to do to win support among the suburban moderates needed to win in Minnesota. If Coleman faces off against Al Franken, it'll be a blow out in favor of Coleman. If Mike Ciresi gets the Democratic nomination, Coleman will win by a more modest margin.
Mississippi--Conventional wisdom is that geriatric Republican Thad Cochran plans to run for re-election. If he does, Election Night 2008 will be another coronation for him. If he doesn't, there's zero chance a Democrat wins a Mississippi Senate race....including former Attorney General Mike Moore who wouldn't get within seven points of a Republican in MS with Hillary or Obama at the top of the ticket.
Montana--It certainly is likely that long-time incumbent Democrat Max Baucus will be re-elected, but in a Presidential election year in Montana, Baucus could conceivably be taken down by a capable Republican challenger.
Nebraska--Unless he runs for President third-party with Mike Bloomberg, Chuck Hagel will be re-elected to the U.S. Senate for Nebraska. If Hagel doesn't run for Senate re-election, another Republican will win the seat.
New Hampshire--Tough call on this one. One-term GOP incumbent John Sununu is definitely vulnerable, but until I know the significance of his future Democratic challenger, I have to give Sununu a slight edge.
New Jersey--Democratic incumbent Frank Lautenberg is a very old man, but nonetheless seems poised to run for another term in the Senate next year. Lautenberg has low approval ratings, but so do all New Jersey politicians. I'm confident Lautenberg will dispatch any Republican challenger that might be thrown at him.
New Mexico--Pete Domenici is in hot water over his role in the U.S. Attorney firings....and may retire anyway. My bet is that Domenici runs again and gets re-elected. If he doesn't run, the Democrats may have a slight advantage in winning the open seat, but only a tiny one if Republican Congresswoman Heather Wilson runs (even though I doubt she'd abandon her House seat).
North Carolina--Lame Republican incumbent Elizabeth Dole is vulnerable, but it would take a special kind of Democrat to defeat her in a Presidential election year. Governor Mike Easley might be such a guy, but even in an Easley-Dole faceoff, I'd have to give a slight advantage to Dole considering the circumstances. Winnable, but an extreme longshot. I said last year that I expected it to be a generation before a Democrat won another Senate seat in the Old Confederacy outside of Arkansas. I still feel that way.
Oklahoma--Wingnut Republican James Inhofe is a shoo-in for re-election.
Oregon--Moderate Republican Gordon Smith is gonna be very hard to take down no matter which Democrat challenges him. I'll be stunned if Smith gets beaten.
Rhode Island--Democrat Jack Reed wins in a landslide.
South Carolina--He might face a tough primary challenge on the right for cooperating too much with those nasty Democrats, but Republican Lindsay Graham will nonetheless prevail handily in both the primary and the general election.
South Dakota--I'm doubtful that Democrat Tim Johnson will be well enough to run for re-election next year. If he isn't, Republicans will be strongly favored to pick up this seat. Democratic Congresswoman Stephanie Herseth may have even odds if she decided to run, but I honestly hope she doesn't because we can't afford to lose that House seat for a Senate run gamble. Bottom line: I'm betting the GOP gains a seat here.
Tennessee--Republican Lamar Alexander crushes any Democratic challenger that steps in his path.
Texas--The Democrats are delusionally optimistic about toppling one-term incumbent John Cornyn....in Texas.....with either Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, or John Edwards at the top of the ticket. I can't think of any Texas Democrat capable of getting within five points of Cornyn.....or any other candidate with an (R) next to his name for that matter.
Virginia--If Republican John Warner decides to run for another term (pretty much even odds on that bet right now), he'll win. If he doesn't, the Democrats have a modest chance of picking up a seat, particularly if former Governor Mark Warner runs. But the Republicans have a pretty solid bench of their own in Virginia, so don't count them out even if Warner (John that is) ends up retiring.
West Virginia--I submit that Shelley Moore Capito could take Democratic incumbent Jay Rockefeller if she challenged him in increasingly Republican West Virginia, but there's no indication that will happen at this stage, and until it does, you have to bet on Rockefeller.
Wyoming--Republican incumbent Mike Enzi is re-elected handily.
So there you have it. Even under my most optimistic prognosis, the Democrats are only poised to net one seat in 2008. It's way too early to give any merit to these predictions, but I'd be shocked if either party gained more than two seats in the 2008 cycle. It'll be interesting to watch the contests unfold in the months ahead.