In the latest disappointment for Democrats, incumbent Rhode Island Senator Lincoln Chafee survived his primary challenge on Tuesday night against conservative Steve Laffey, even though the smart money was on Laffey leading up to the election. Had Laffey won, the Republicans planned to abandon their presence in the race, conceding defeat to Democratic challenger Sheldon Whitehouse. The survival of Chafee, the most liberal Republican in Congress, ensures the GOP has at least a 50-50 chance of holding this seat.
Now you'll rarely hear me say this about a Republican, but Chafee is an admirable guy. Of all the Republicans who claim to be "independent" from the Bush administration and the noxious Congressional GOP leadership, Chafee is one of the few who can actually be believed. Most years, I wouldn't lament his re-election and would even find him to be a useful check-and-balance against a Democratic President if there was one in office. Today, however, all that matters is Democrats seizing control of any branch of government they can as a counteragent for the Bush-Frist-Hastert cabal.....and Chafee serves no purpose towards that end.
Ultimately saving Chafee in his 54-46 victory were independent voters who crossed over to vote in the GOP primary because they like Chafee. My concern is that these same independent voters, most of whom despise Bush if polling data from sapphire-blue Rhode Island can be believed, will disproportionately vote for Chafee again in November, dronishly and inadvertantly installing Mitch McConnell as Senate Majority Leader. The only good news for Democrats in Rhode Island is that they swamped the GOP in turnout even though there were no hotly-contested races. In fact, Whitehouse got more votes than both Laffey and Chafee combined. That's an optimistic sign that there may be enough Rhode Islanders who see the big picture to vote for a real Democrat in November rather than the faux-Democrat Chafee.
In more primary news, controversy-plagued Keith Ellison was victorious in a hotly-contested three-way battle for the open MN-05 Congressional seat in Minneapolis. This guy makes me nervous at a number of levels. Aside for his past ties to Louis Farrakahn and his refusal to follow the laws that he passes (unpaid taxes, unpaid parking tickets, tardy submission of election application forms), he just doesn't strike me as a likable guy. A controversial politician at least has to be likable to be successful, but anybody except the hard-core DFL ideologues will be unlikely to take to the abrasive and scowly Ellison. Hopefully, the guy pleasantly surprises me and his constituents. Given that his district is 72% Democratic, there's no doubt he'll be elected in the fall against GOP challenger Alan Fine, but if Fine is pulling in 38-40% of the vote in MN-05 because Golden Valley soccer moms have too many concerns about his ethics issues to vote for him, it'll be a potential millstone around the necks of other DFL candidates running statewide, particularly Klobuchar and Hatch.
Like Rhode Island, turnout among Democrats was robust in Minnesota, even without any top-tier or even second-tier races on the itinerary (only Becky Lourey's true believers took her challenge to Mike Hatch in the gubernatorial race seriously). The DFL swamped Republican turnout statewide by a nearly 2-1 margin in Minnesota, with Klobuchar besting Kennedy in Wright County (his home county) and Hatch beating Pawlenty in Dakota County (Pawlenty's stomping grounds). These figures are unlikely to hold in November, but gives a decent indication of how demoralized and disengaged Minnesota Republicans are this election cycle.
The Dems are very cocky about their prospects in AZ-08 with the victory of hard-right talk show host Randy Graf, whose main issue is illegal immigration, over party-supported moderate Steve Huffman. Most Democratic pundits and media analysts now lean this race to photogenic Democratic candidate Gabrielle Giffords. I'm not convined. Immigration is the top concern of Arizona residents, and their allegiance is much closer to Graf than that of the McCain-Kennedy bill. If Graf comes across like a civilized guy with an articulate anti-immigration position, I expect he'll win. The Dems thought they were scare Oklahomans by caricuratizing extreme-right 2004 Senate candidate Tom Coburn as a foaming-at-the-mouth nutball, but when Coburn actually talked to people and came across as a normal guy, traditional partisan allegiances helped drag Coburn come from behind to score a double-digit victory over Democratic challenger Brad Carson come election night. Considering that AZ-08 still leans ever-so-slightly to the GOP, I'm expecting a similar scenario could play out with Graf this year considering his key issue aligns with that of southern Arizonans.
Overall, the night wasn't as horrific as it could have been. Ben Cardin beat Kweisi Mfume by a solid eight-point margin in the Maryland Senate race, keeping the Democratic advantage against Michael Steele in that contest, but probably creating an uncomfortable racial dynamic that presents a needle for Democrats to thread. Still, that Rhode Island contest was a heartbreaker. Watching those returns come in for Chafee last night, I felt the same sinking feeling in my gut that I felt on the nightmarish election nights of 2002 and 2004, and I fear there be may more disappointment where that came from this November. The Democrats need to OWN independent voters to take back either House of Congress. The fact that so many showed up to save Lincoln Chafee in a Republican primary tells me we're gonna fall short once again.